About
The Silver Penny
Our Store
A passion for the old and gently used turned into a unique collection of can't live without items.
Nestled in the heart of the Laurel Highlands, The Silver Penny is a delightful vintage shop that invites visitors to step back in time and explore a world of unique treasures. Owned and passionately curated by Karen Temple, the shop specializes in hard goods and housewares, offering a carefully selected assortment of items that span decades of design and craftsmanship.
Karen’s expertise and keen eye for quality ensure that every piece in The Silver Penny has a story to tell. From elegant mid-century ceramics to quirky retro kitchen gadgets, there’s something for every taste and style.
Shoppers can expect to find an ever-changing inventory that reflects both timeless elegance and eclectic charm.
What sets The Silver Penny apart is not just its collection, but the warm and welcoming atmosphere that Karen has cultivated. Whether you're a seasoned collector, a curious newcomer, or simply someone looking for a special gift, Karen is always ready to share her knowledge and help you find the perfect item.
At The Silver Penny, every visit is an opportunity to discover pieces that aren’t just decorative, but also imbued with history and character. It’s a haven for those who appreciate the beauty of yesteryears and the stories that vintage items carry with them.
Our Story
In 1987, Karen and her husband John acquired the building that now houses The Silver Penny. What was once a dilapidated gas station appeared to be a daunting project for the young couple with three daughters. As renovations commenced, a vision for their family's future began to. Karen opened her first shop in 1990, initially on furniture and clothing, and quickly discovered her talent for finding unique items. Over the years, she shifted her focus away from clothing to concentrate on furniture and home decor.
In 2008, Karen and John transitioned from the used goods business to owning Hometown Pizza & More. Karen managed the pizza shop for eight years before deciding to return to vintage home goods, running both businesses until she ultimately chose to dedicate herself fully to her store.
In August 2020, The Silver Penny moved from its previous location at 3919 State Route 31 to the old Hometown Pizza building at 4026 State Route 31, just down the hill. The new shop features over 2,000 square feet of showroom space, ready to showcase your next great find!
